• Skip to main content
  • Skip to secondary menu
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

The NOTL Local

  • Home
  • News
  • Culture
  • Sports
  • Opinion
  • Events
  • Contact
  • Current Edition
  • Buy Membership
  • Membership Offers
  •  
Home / News / Changes to conservation authority legislation a concern

Changes to conservation authority legislation a concern

January 1, 2021 by Penny Coles News

This is the view from the Virgil conservation area around Four Mile Creek. Natural areas and watersheds such as these lose protection under new provincial legislation. (Owen Bjorgan)

 Although the Niagara Peninsula Conservation Authority, and others across the province, asked for more time and discussion about recent changes to legislation that oversees their work, their requests were unheeded.

The bill passed in December, with significant changes to the provincial Conservation Authorities Act that are concerning, says Niagara-on-the-Lake’s Regional Coun. Gary Zalepa.

One change that has garnered attention and opposition requires conservation authorities to issue a development permit when the Minister of Municipal Affairs and Housing issues Ministers Zoning Orders (MZO), which can override conservation authority decisions that have been made based on science and environmental protection.

The legislation undermines the ability for the NPCA to make decisions on the protection of ecosystems and floodplains, says Zalepa, with no avenue for appeal.

Conservation authorities across Ontario endorsed a resolution to ask the Province to address their concerns by repealing, amending or at least delaying changes to the act, but that didn’t happen.

“Any time government wants to make some broad changes, it really should gather input from as many people as possible, because that’s how you make a better decision. In this case that didn’t happen, and that concerns me,” says Zalepa. “I don’t know why it didn’t happen. I can’t read the government’s intentions. It doesn’t appear to be a fulsome process, and I think process is really important.”

The other issue of concern is the new requirement for members of conservation authority boards to be elected officials, says Zalepa.

After the 2018 municipal election and the overthrow of the previous NPCA board members amid controversy, Niagara regional councillors were appointed to replace them as interim members. Zalepa was nominated as Niagara-on-the-Lake’s representative. NPCA governance had become the subject of criticism locally and from the Province, and the board of regional councillors was put in place to elect a new CAO to the conservation authority, and straighten out issues of governance, staffing and budget that had come to light during the previous term, with the intention of replacing those councillors when their work was done with citizen members with relevant skills and knowledge

St. Davids resident Dr. William Rapley was recommended to replace Zalepa on the NPCA Board and became NOTL’s representative once those issues were resolved.

The interim board of elected officials accomplished what it set out to do, says Zalepa, and the current board of mostly citizen representatives is also working well.

“In Niagara, we’ve struck a balance between elected and non-elected people, and that so far has worked well. Conservation authorities were designed to have broad representation on the board. I think it’s a flawed rationale to have only elected representatives for accountability reasons. In Niagara we saw a complete failure of good governance through the conservation authority’s composition of mostly elected people. At that point politics was driving the bus, rather than good policy.”

The current provincial decisions appear to be politically motivated, says Zalepa. “I don’t know why they would do something without a fulsome discussion.”

Ambiguity and lack of clarity in provincial environmental policy has long been an issue, and will continue to be, says Zalepa.

Decisions of development in provincially-significant areas have  “sometimes been managed effectively, and sometimes not so effectively by conservation authorities and municipalities,” says Zalepa.

“In Niagara, a lack of clarity in provincial policy allowed people to manage the authority as they wanted. That still happens across the province, those problems still exist, with a lack of policy from the top.”

That lack of clarity allows for political decisions to be made, he says.

“We really need to take a step back, and do what the people of Ontario really want and need. That’s not happening. What we really need is clarity about the guidelines, and how to implement them. That’s not going to happen, and that’s problematic.”

Lack of policy should have been dealt with, and hasn’t been, by this provincial government or others before it, says Zalepa, allowing municipalities to make decisions that may or may not consider what is best for protecting ecosystems and managing flooding and drainage issues.

Those issues have a financial cost, he added, referring to the doubling of regional insurance liability cost due to flooding that has damaged infrastructure.

Regional council will discuss the impact of the provincial legislation Wednesday, Jan. 13, says Zalepa. 

Primary Sidebar

Upcoming Events

  1. Friday Night Trivia ~ “Friends”

    April 23 @ 7:30 pm - 8:00 pm

    Join us this Friday when the Trivia will be all about the show Friends.  Gather the gang and get competitive!  Join us for a virtual trivia night from the comfort of your couch.  Play on your phone, computer or tablet, no app needed just a web browser.  All are welcome! Log On To:  CROWD.LIVE Enter […]

  2. Niagara Pumphouse ~ April Family Friendly Online Studio

    April 24 @ 11:00 am - 4:00 pm

    Learn to make a Stained Glass Suncatcher! Hang your masterpiece on your window for a colourful Spring décor.  For details, please visit:  https://niagarapumphouse.ca For this project, you will need: – Wax paper or plastic page protector – Printout of templates (download templates below) – mixed tissue paper cut into squares – white glue – container […]

  3. Monday Makers: Create with Kasia ~Virtually! Ages 7 – 13

    April 24 @ 4:30 pm - 5:30 pm

    Join us for a fun and creative art break for your brain! PANDA PAINTING: Join Kasia to learn how to make a fun and easy mixed-media masterpiece with a cute panda and green leafy bamboo.  No experience necessary! Participants are asked to visit https://notlpubliclibrary.org to pre-register for April 26th.  Once registered, you will receive an […]

  4. Monday Makers: Create with Kasia ~ Virtually! Ages 7 – 13

    April 26 @ 4:30 pm - 5:30 pm

    Join us for a fun and creative art break for your brain! PANDA PAINTING: Join Kasia to learn how to make a fun and easy mixed-media masterpiece with a cute panda and green leafy bamboo.  No experience necessary! Participants are asked to visit https://notlpubliclibrary.org to pre-register.  Once registered, you will receive an email with details […]

  5. Author Talks ~ Jennifer Robson ~ 14+

    April 28 @ 7:00 pm - 8:00 pm

    Join us in welcoming Jennifer Robson as our next author in our 2021 Author Talk Series!  Enjoy an evening with writer Jennifer Robson from the comfort of your home as she talks about her book “Our Darkest Night”.  Although we will be apart there will be plenty of time for questions and conversation.  This free […]

View All Events

Footer

About Us

The Niagara-on-the-Lake Local and notllocal.com were established in 2018 to be your community newspaper. We hope you will think of us as The Local, representing the heart and soul of the community you call home.

I want to…

  • Send a letter to the editor
  • Submit a community event
  • Advertise with The Niagara-on-the-Lake Local

Connect With Us

  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Twitter

© 2021 · Site Design and Hosting by The GDC Group